Would You Rather Halloween Questions

31 Fun And Scary Would You Rather Halloween Questions

Would love some shares, thank you!

This post may contain affiliate links. I may receive commissions for purchases made through these links with no extra cost to you. See full disclosure.

Last Updated on September 15, 2023 by Yvette’s Treasures

Fun And Scary Would You Rather Halloween Questions

Table of Contents

Ready to test your Halloween spirit with some spine-tingling dilemmas? This article presents a thrilling collection of “Would You Rather” Halloween questions that will challenge your bravery and creativity.

From choosing between trick or treating in a haunted house or a graveyard to deciding whether you would rather be a vampire or a werewolf for a day, these thought-provoking scenarios will have you pondering long after the last ghosts and goblins have gone. So brace yourself, get into the Halloween mood, and get ready to make some haunted decisions!

Would You Rather Halloween Questions (2)


Get 30 FREE Halloween “would you rather questions” near the bottom of the post! All you need to do is download, print and play the game with family and friends . Enjoy!


Halloween Would You Rather Costume Choices

Traditional vs Creative Costumes

When it comes to choosing a Halloween costume, you have a decision to make – do you go with a traditional costume or get creative? Traditional costumes, like vampires, witches, and ghosts, are always a classic choice.

They are instantly recognizable and can be easily put together with items you might already have in your closet. On the other hand, creative costumes allow you to showcase your unique personality and imagination.

Whether you opt for a clever pun costume or transform into a character from your favorite movie like Harry Potter or TV show, the possibilities are endless. With a creative costume, you have the chance to stand out and impress your friends with your ingenuity.

Scary vs Funny Costumes

Another aspect to consider when choosing a Halloween costume is whether you want to go for a scary or funny look. Scary costumes, such as zombies, witches, or monsters, can bring a sense of fear and thrill to the Halloween atmosphere.

They allow you to embrace the darker side of the holiday and create a spine-chilling presence. On the other hand, funny costumes can bring joy and laughter to the festivities.

Dressing up as a funny character or sporting a humorous costume can lighten the mood and ensure a night filled with smiles and giggles.

Ultimately, the choice between scary and funny costumes depends on your personal preference and the type of experience you want to have on Halloween.


DIY vs Store-Bought Costumes

Now that you have an idea of the type of costume you want, you need to decide whether you want to go the DIY route or purchase a ready-made costume.

DIY costumes allow you to unleash your creativity and customize every detail. You can utilize your crafting skills to make a costume that is truly one-of-a-kind and tailored to your preferences.

This option can also be more budget-friendly since you can use items you already have at home or find inexpensive materials. On the other hand, store-bought costumes offer convenience and often come with high-quality materials and intricate designs.

They can save you time and effort, especially if you are short on crafting skills or prefer a more polished look. Ultimately, the choice between DIY and store-bought costumes depends on your available resources and how much time and effort you want to invest in creating your Halloween look for your Halloween party.


Candy vs Non-Candy Treats

The most exciting part of Halloween for many is going trick-or-treating and collecting delicious treats. But what type of treats do you prefer? Are you all about the candy, or do you lean towards non-candy treats?

Candy treats, such as chocolate bars, gummy worms, and lollipops, are a classic Halloween staple that brings immense joy to both children and adults.

The thrill of sorting through your loot and finding your favorite candies is hard to beat. However, non-candy treats, such as small toys, stickers, or mini puzzles, can provide a fun and unique alternative.

They offer a break from the sugar rush and can be a great option for children with dietary restrictions or allergies. Whether you prefer to eat candy corn or non-candy treats, the joy of receiving goodies while trick-or-treating is sure to make your Halloween even sweeter.

Safe Neighborhood vs Haunted House

When it comes to selecting a trick-or-treating location, do you prefer a safe neighborhood or a haunted house experience? Trick-or-treating in a safe neighborhood offers a comfortable and family-friendly environment.

Well-lit streets, friendly neighbors, and a sense of community create a pleasant experience for kids and their families. On the other hand, some thrill-seekers might prefer the excitement of visiting a haunted house.

These elaborately decorated houses or attractions offer a spooky and immersive environment. You never know what surprises and scares await as you navigate through the dimly lit corridors and encounter eerie characters.

Whether you prefer a safe neighborhood or a haunted house, the key is to choose an atmosphere that aligns with your preferences and comfort level.

Trick-or-Treating Alone vs in a Group

The question now is whether you prefer trick-or-treating alone or with a group of friends. Going trick-or-treating alone can be a liberating experience.

You can set your own pace, visit the houses you want, and enjoy the thrill of independence. It provides a quiet and introspective adventure, allowing you to fully immerse yourself in the Halloween spirit.

On the other hand, going trick-or-treating in a group can be a fun and memorable experience. Dressing up together, laughing, and exploring the neighborhood as a team enhances the sense of camaraderie and creates lasting memories.

Additionally, going in a group can offer a sense of safety and security, especially for younger trick-or-treaters. Whether you choose to go alone or with a group, the important thing is to enjoy the moment and make the most out of your spooky Halloween adventure.

Halloween Activities Would You Rather Questions

Pumpkin Carving vs Apple Bobbing

October wouldn’t be complete without engaging in fun Halloween activities. One popular activity is pumpkin carving, where you get to unleash your creative side and transform a simple pumpkin into a spooky or intricate masterpiece.

This activity allows you to showcase your artistic skills and create a unique decoration for your home. Alternatively, apple bobbing is a classic Halloween game that brings laughter and excitement.

Dipping your face into a barrel filled with water to catch apples with your teeth is a fun and challenging experience. It brings out the competitive spirit and adds a touch of nostalgia to your Halloween celebrations.

So Whether you choose pumpkin carving or apple bobbing, you’re sure to have a great time enjoying these traditional activities.

Haunted Hayride vs Haunted House


Halloween Would You Rather

For those seeking a spine-chilling experience, both haunted hayrides and haunted houses offer a thrilling adventure. Haunted hayrides take you on a journey through a dark and eerie path, often surrounded by fog and accompanied by spooky sound effects.

As you ride through the haunting scenes and encounter terrifying characters, your heart races with anticipation and fear. On the other hand, haunted houses provide a more immersive experience, where you walk through rooms filled with elaborate decorations and encounter actors in creepy costumes.

The close proximity and interactive nature of haunted houses intensify the scare factor, leaving you with an unforgettable experience. If you choose a haunted hayride or a haunted house, prepare yourself for a thrilling ride filled with frights and surprises.

Scary Movie Marathon vs Costume Party

Halloween activities wouldn’t be complete without deciding between a scary movie marathon or a costume party. If you’re a fan of horror movies, a scary movie marathon might be the perfect choice for you.

You can snuggle up on the couch, turn off the lights, and immerse yourself in a world of suspense, jump scares, and supernatural thrills.

From cult classics to modern horror favorites, there’s a wide range of films to choose from that will keep you on the edge of your seat all night long.

On the other hand, if you prefer a more social and festive atmosphere, a costume party might be the way to go. Dressing up with friends, dancing to spooky tunes, and enjoying Halloween candy and drinks can create a lively and vibrant celebration.

Whether you choose to watch horror movies or a hold a costume party, both options promise a night filled with Halloween spirit and entertainment.

Halloween Food

Caramel Apples vs Pumpkin Pie

Halloween isn’t just about spooky costumes and scary activities; it’s also about indulging in delicious treats. One popular Halloween food choice is between caramel apples and pumpkin pie.

Caramel apples offer the perfect combination of sweet and crunchy. The crisp apple coated in sticky caramel creates a delightful contrast of flavors and textures.

It’s a classic Halloween treat that brings back childhood memories and satisfies your sweet tooth. On the other hand, pumpkin pie embodies the essence of fall.

The warm and comforting flavors of cinnamon, nutmeg, and pumpkin make it a must-have during the Halloween season. The rich and creamy texture of the pie, coupled with the aromatic spices, creates a treat that is perfect for cozying up on a chilly autumn night.

You’re in for a delectable Halloween dessert whether you choose to eat pumpkin pie or caramel apples.

Candy Corn vs Chocolate Bars

Another confectionery debate often arises around Halloween – candy corn vs chocolate bars. Candy corn is a polarizing candy that people either love or hate. Its vibrant colors and unique shape make it an iconic Halloween treat.

With its sugary sweetness and chewy texture, candy corn provides a burst of flavor that takes you straight back to childhood. On the other hand, chocolate bars are a timeless indulgence that never fails to satisfy.

From classic milk chocolate bars to assortments of miniature treats, chocolate offers a variety of flavors and options to suit every taste. The smooth and velvety texture of chocolate melts in your mouth, creating a moment of pure bliss.

Should your preference lean towards candy corn or chocolate bars, there’s no denying that both options bring joy and delight to your Halloween festivities.

Halloween Themed Drinks vs Regular Drinks

To quench your thirst during your Halloween celebrations, you have the choice between Halloween themed drinks or regular drinks. Halloween themed drinks, such as witches’ brew punch or vampire blood cocktails, add a touch of creativity and fun to your beverages.

These concoctions often feature vibrant colors, eerie garnishes, and spooky names that enhance the Halloween atmosphere. Sipping on a themed drink can make you feel like you’re indulging in a magical potion or a mysterious elixir.

On the other hand, regular drinks offer familiarity and versatility. Your favorite soda, juice, or hot beverage can still complement your Halloween activities and provide refreshment without the extra frills.

So whether you opt for Halloween themed drinks, drink apple cider or regular drinks, the choice is yours, any one of these options will keep you hydrated as you celebrate this festive holiday.

Would You Rather Questions Halloween Decorations

Spooky vs Cute Décor

When it comes to decorating your home for Halloween, you have the option of going for a spooky or cute theme. Spooky decorations, such as skeletons, ghosts, and cobwebs, create an eerie ambiance that sends shivers down your spine.

These decorations embrace the darker side of Halloween and make your home feel like a haunted abode. On the other hand, cute decorations, like smiling pumpkins, friendly ghosts, a cute black cat and adorable witches, bring a lighthearted and playful touch to your Halloween décor.

They can create a more family-friendly atmosphere and make the decorations appealing to children. Whether you prefer a spooky or cute theme, decorating your home for Halloween adds a touch of magic and sets the stage for a memorable holiday.

DIY Decorations vs Store-Bought Decorations

When it comes to Halloween decorations, you can choose between DIY creations or purchasing ready-made decorations. DIY decorations allow you to unleash your creativity and personalize every detail.

From crafting paper bats to carving intricate pumpkins, the possibilities are endless. Creating your own decorations can also be a fun project to involve your family or friends, providing an opportunity to bond and bring your artistic visions to life.

Then again, store-bought decorations offer convenience and often come with intricate designs and special effects. They can save you time and effort, especially if you’re short on crafting skills or prefer a more polished look.

Whether you opt for DIY decorations or some of these fun store-bought decorations, the important thing is to infuse your home with the Halloween spirit and create an enchanting and bewitching atmosphere.

Cobwebs vs Hanging Bats


would you rather Halloween


Within your chosen theme and decorations, you may have to decide between cobwebs or hanging bats. Cobwebs are a staple Halloween decoration that instantly adds a spooky and haunted touch to any space.

Draped over furniture, corners, or doorways, they create an atmosphere of abandonment and mystery. As the cobwebs catch the light and move subtly with the wind, they give your home an authentic haunted house feel.

Otherwise, hanging bats bring a sense of movement and liveliness to your decorations. Suspended from the ceiling or walls, they add a dynamic element to your Halloween setup.

Their presence evokes the mystique of creatures of the night and enhances the overall ambiance. Whether you choose cobwebs or hanging bats, these small details can make a big impact on your Halloween décor.

Halloween Music

Thriller by Michael Jackson vs Monster Mash

No Halloween celebration is complete without a soundtrack to set the mood. Two iconic Halloween songs often go head-to-head – “Thriller” by Michael Jackson and “Monster Mash.” “Thriller” is an undeniable Halloween anthem that brings together the smooth vocals of Michael Jackson with an infectious beat and a captivating storyline.

Its chilling music video, featuring iconic dance moves and a cast of zombies, has become a hallmark of the Halloween season. On the other hand, “Monster Mash” is a playful and catchy tune that celebrates the supernatural creatures that come out to play on Halloween night.

With its humorous lyrics and energetic melody, it’s a song that inspires dancing and laughter. Whether you prefer the thrilling allure of “Thriller” or the lightheartedness of “Monster Mash,” both songs are guaranteed to get you in the Halloween spirit.

Spooky Sound Effects vs Halloween Pop Hits

In addition to iconic Halloween songs, you have the choice between spooky sound effects or a playlist of Halloween pop hits. Spooky sound effects, such as creaking floors, howling wind, and sinister laughter, add an immersive layer to your Halloween atmosphere.

They can create a sense of anticipation and send shivers down your spine as you navigate through the haunting ambiance. On the other hand, a playlist of Halloween pop hits offers a lively and diverse selection of songs that invoke the spirit of the holiday.

From classics like “Ghostbusters” to modern hits like “This Is Halloween,” these songs bring energy and familiarity to your celebrations.

Whether you opt for spooky sound effects or a playlist of Halloween pop hits, the music you choose will enhance the festive atmosphere and add an extra layer of fun to your Halloween festivities.

Creepy Classical Music vs Spooky Rock Anthems


Would You Rather Questions Halloween


For those with more refined music preferences, the choice often lies between creepy classical music and spooky rock anthems. Creepy classical music, such as “Night on Bald Mountain” by Mussorgsky or “Danse Macabre” by Saint-Saëns, offers a haunting and atmospheric experience.

The symphonic melodies and dramatic compositions transport you to a world filled with mystery and darkness. On the other hand, spooky rock anthems, like “Black Magic Woman” by Santana or “Welcome to My Nightmare” by Alice Cooper, infuse Halloween spirit into the realm of rock music.

These exhilarating tunes bring a blend of energy, rebellion, and a touch of the macabre to your Halloween celebrations. Whether you prefer creepy classical music or spooky rock anthems, both genres offer a captivating and evocative sound that will immerse you in the Halloween ambiance.

Halloween Traditions

Carving Jack-O’-Lanterns vs Making Paper Ghosts

Halloween traditions vary from household to household, and two popular ones often emerge – carving Jack-o’-lanterns or making paper ghosts.

Carving Jack-o’-lanterns is a classic Halloween activity that allows you to create illuminated works of art out of pumpkins. Whether you go for a spooky face or a more intricate design, the flickering glow of a candle inside a carved pumpkin adds a magical touch to your Halloween décor.

Instead, making paper ghosts brings a crafty and creative element to your traditions. Cutting out white paper into ghostly shapes and stringing them together can create an adorable and whimsical decoration that adds a touch of playfulness to your home.

Whether you choose to carve Jack-o’-lanterns or make paper ghosts, these traditions are a fun and engaging way to celebrate and embrace the Halloween spirit.

Bobbing for Apples vs Telling Ghost Stories


Would You Rather Questions funny


Another Halloween tradition often debated is whether to bob for apples or gather around for ghost stories. Bobbing for apples is a festive and entertaining game that is perfect for Halloween parties and gatherings.

Filling a large basin with water and floating apples, participants take turns attempting to catch an apple using only their mouth, often resulting in playful laughter and wet faces.

This lively activity adds an element of friendly competition and nostalgic charm to your Halloween celebrations. On the other hand, telling ghost stories is a more intimate and spine-chilling tradition that brings people together in a circle of suspense.

Gathering around a dimly lit room, sharing terrifying tales of the supernatural, and listening to the haunting silence creates a unique bonding experience and sparks the imagination.

Should you choose to bob for apples or tell ghost stories, both traditions offer a chance to connect with others and create lasting memories on Halloween night.

Visiting Haunted Houses vs Going to Halloween Parades

The final choice in Halloween traditions often centers around visiting haunted houses or going to Halloween parades. Visiting a haunted house is an immersive and thrilling experience that allows you to step into the world of the supernatural.

If it’s a professional haunted attraction or a homemade spooky setup, these houses provide a chance to confront your fears, test your bravery, and enjoy a night filled with heart-stopping scares.

Alternatively, attending a Halloween parade is a lively and colorful tradition that brings communities together. Watching floats, performers, and participants dressed in elaborate costumes parade down the streets creates a vibrant and festive atmosphere.

It’s a chance to appreciate the creativity of others, join in the revelry, and celebrate Halloween as a community. Whether you choose to visit haunted houses or go to Halloween parades, both traditions offer a unique and unforgettable experience that captures the essence of the holiday.

Halloween Films – Scary Would You Rather Questions

Classic Horror Films vs Modern Horror Films


horror films


For movie buffs, the choice between classic horror films and modern horror films can be a tough one. Classic horror films, such as “Psycho” or “The Exorcist,” set the foundation for the genre and have become timeless masterpieces.

They rely on suspense, atmospheric tension, and psychological thrills to evoke fear in the audience. Watching these classics can provide a sense of nostalgia and a deeper appreciation for the origins of horror cinema.

Then again, modern horror films offer fresh takes on the genre, incorporating new techniques and storytelling methods. With advances in special effects and a focus on visual scares, modern horror films aim to push the boundaries and keep audiences on the edge of their seats.

Whether you prefer classic horror films or modern horror films, both options offer a chance to dive into the eerie and captivating world of the supernatural.

Slasher Films vs Supernatural Horror Films

Within the horror genre, another popular choice arises – slasher films or supernatural horror films. Slasher films, like “Halloween” or “Friday the 13th,” center around a serial killer or a masked villain hunting down unsuspecting victims.

These films rely on gruesome violence, tension-filled chase scenes, and psychological terror to elicit fear in the audience. They provide an adrenaline rush and capitalize on the fear of the unknown lurking in the shadows.

Alternatively, supernatural horror films, such as The Conjuring, Zombie Apocalypse or Insidious, explore the realms of the paranormal and the supernatural. Ghosts, demons, and otherworldly creatures become the main source of horror.

These films tap into our deepest fears, exploiting the vulnerability of the human psyche and introducing elements that defy logic. Whether you prefer slasher films or supernatural horror films, both subgenres offer a chilling and captivating experience for fans of the macabre.

Family-Friendly Halloween Movies vs Gory Halloween Movies

Halloween films cater to diverse audiences, and the debate between family-friendly Halloween movies and gory Halloween movies is a significant one. Family-friendly Halloween movies, such as “Hocus Pocus” or “The Nightmare Before Christmas,” offer a delightful and whimsical experience suitable for all ages.

These films balance comedy, magic, and a touch of spookiness to create a heartwarming and enchanting narrative. They provide a sense of nostalgia and create lasting memories for families watching together. On the other hand, gory Halloween movies, like “Saw” or “Texas Chainsaw Massacre,” cater to a more mature audience seeking intense thrills and shocking visuals.

These films push the boundaries of horror with graphic violence and disturbing images that leave a lasting impact. Whether you prefer family-friendly Halloween movies or gory Halloween movies, both options offer a chance to immerse yourself in the Halloween spirit and enjoy the cinematic experience.

Halloween Party Games

Pin the Spider on the Web vs Mummy Wrap Race

For those seeking Halloween-themed games, the choice often lies between pin the spider on the web or a mummy wrap race. Pin the spider on the web is a spin-off of the classic party game “Pin the Tail on the Donkey.” Blindfolded participants attempt to attach a paper spider to a large spiderweb poster, adding a touch of Halloween spin to the traditional game.

The anticipation and laughter that ensue as players attempt to strategically place the spider create an engaging and entertaining activity for all ages. On the other hand, a mummy wrap race adds an element of competition and physicality to your Halloween celebrations.

Participants divide into teams, with each team wrapping one member in toilet paper to create a mummy-like figure. The first team to fully wrap their teammate wins the race.

This high-energy and hilarious game encourages teamwork and laughter. Whether you choose to pin the spider on the web or engage in a mummy wrap race, both games offer a chance to have fun, bond with others, and create unforgettable Halloween memories.

Halloween Bingo vs Monster Freeze Dance


Family-Friendly Movies


Another choice in Halloween games often arises between Halloween Bingo and Monster Freeze Dance. Halloween Bingo is a traditional game with a spooky twist.

Participants receive bingo cards featuring Halloween-themed images, and a caller randomly selects and announces the images. Players mark off the corresponding images on their cards, and the first one to achieve a complete line or pattern yells “Bingo!”

This friendly game encourages concentration, memory, and a dash of luck. On the other hand, Monster Freeze Dance brings music and movement to your Halloween festivities.

Participants dance to Halloween-themed songs, but when the music stops, they freeze in place. Anyone caught moving after the music stops is out.

The last player standing becomes the winner. Monster Freeze Dance adds laughter, creativity, and excitement to your Halloween celebrations. Whether you choose Halloween Bingo or Monster Freeze Dance, both games offer a chance to engage in friendly competition and have a blast.

Bobbing for Eyeballs vs Pumpkin Bowling

The final choice in Halloween games often comes down to bobbing for eyeballs or pumpkin bowling. Bobbing for eyeballs is a spooky and sensory-intensive game that challenges participants to retrieve floating eyeballs from a basin using only their mouths.

It’s a thrilling and unforgettable experience that generates laughter and squeals of delight. This game adds an element of surprise and excitement to your Halloween festivities.

On the other hand, pumpkin bowling transforms a simple activity into a festive and Halloween-themed game. Participants roll a small pumpkin towards a set of pins, aiming to knock down as many as possible.

This game encourages focus, accuracy, and a bit of friendly competition. Whether you choose to bob for eyeballs or engage in pumpkin bowling, both games offer a chance to have fun, test your skills, and embrace the playful side of Halloween.

Halloween Pranks

Fake Spider vs Jump Scare

For those who enjoy a good prank, the decision often revolves around a fake spider or a jump scare. Placing a fake spider in unexpected places can send shivers down the spines of unsuspecting victims.

Whether it’s hiding the spider in a shoe or dropping it from above, the reactions and screams are sure to be priceless. This prank adds a touch of harmless fear and surprise to your Halloween celebrations.

On the other hand, a jump scare relies on the element of surprise to startle and shock someone. By hiding and unexpectedly popping out or triggering a sudden loud noise, you create a moment of pure fright.

This prank generates immediate adrenaline and guarantees a memorable reaction. Whether you choose a fake spider or a jump scare, both pranks offer a chance to create laughter, a few scares, and unforgettable memories during the spookiest time of the year.

Toilet Papering a House vs Ding Dong Ditch

Another choice in Halloween pranks often emerges between toilet papering a house or engaging in ding dong ditch. Toilet papering a house involves covering the exterior of a house, particularly trees or shrubs, with rolls of toilet paper.

This mischievous act can create a spectacle and add a touch of Halloween mischief to your neighborhood. It’s important, however, to ensure that the pranks are harmless, respectful, and do not cause any property damage.

Alternatively, ding dong ditch is a classic prank that involves ringing a doorbell or knocking on a door and then running away before the homeowner can answer.

This harmless prank creates a sense of anticipation and excitement, as you try to avoid getting caught in the act. Whether you choose to toilet paper a house or engage in ding dong ditch, remember to respect others’ property and participate in pranks responsibly, ensuring a fun and enjoyable Halloween experience for all.

Fake Blood vs Silly String

The final decision in Halloween pranks often boils down to fake blood or silly string. Fake blood allows you to create realistic and gory effects to surprise and shock others.

If you use it for a convincing costume, a haunted house setup, or a scare prank, the sight of fake blood can elicit powerful reactions. It adds a touch of horror and a sense of suspense to your Halloween festivities.

But, silly string offers a playful and lighthearted alternative. Spraying colorful strings of foam onto unsuspecting friends or family members creates moments of laughter and delight.

Silly string adds a touch of fun and whimsy to your Halloween pranks, and it’s easily cleaned up. Whether you choose fake blood or silly string, both pranks offer a chance to create surprises, laughter, and unforgettable moments during your Halloween celebrations.

Halloween Would You Rather Free Printable Ideas

My son and I love to add a few new free would you rather games to our list every year. You can even hand out a few Halloween would you rather questions to dinner guests during the month of October, they would make fantastic conversation starters.

Get 30 of our free Halloween would you rather questions for kids. Just click to open, print, cut out the questions along the dotted line and enjoy with friends and family. Download Here!

Would You Rather Halloween Questions (2)


My Thoughts On Would You Rather Halloween Questions

Halloween offers a fantastic variety of choices in every aspect of the holiday. From costume choices to Halloween traditions, there’s something for everyone to enjoy.

Whether you prefer traditional or creative costumes, scary or funny themes, DIY or store-bought decorations, the key is to embrace the Halloween spirit and have a memorable celebration.

Click here for discounts on Halloween Costumes


More Fun Halloween Themed Posts


Yvette's Treasures
31 Fun And Scary Would You Rather Halloween Questions
Article Name
31 Fun And Scary Would You Rather Halloween Questions
Looking for Halloween inspiration? Check out these spine-tingling "Would You Rather" Halloween questions that challenge your bravery and creativity!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

seventeen − 14 =

Scroll to Top